Yours for the Season by Emily Stone - Book Review

Publication Date: 07th Oct 2025 

Genre: Contemporary Christmas Romance 

3.5 Stars 

One Liner: Hopeful, though it has a couple of heavy themes 

Melanie (Mel) is not having a great year. Her best friend moved across the world, the love of her life dumped her six months ago, and her business, though going well, was draining her energy. 

However, Finn (the love) shows up at her doorstep asking for help. She would have to act as if they had gotten back together to please his mother, who planned an entire week of Christmas events with Mel included. Mel agrees reluctantly, on the condition that she would get to dump him in public, for him to realize how she felt. 

As they spend more time together, they have to figure out what happened and what they want. 

The story comes in Mel’s third-person POV in the current timeline (present tense) and Finn’s third-person POV in the past timeline. 

My Thoughts: 

This is my first book by the author who is famous for stories set in and around Christmas. I like that the writing is easy to read. The pace is neither slow nor fast. It is steady. 

I won’t talk about the premise since I requested the book knowing what it is. I was curious to see how it would be executed. Been reading second-chance romance more lately (professional research purposes). 

The chapters dealing with the past come from the MMC’s POV, which is a good idea. The timeline is very clear, so we can see the progress in their relationships and know the undercurrents as well. 

The side characters are interesting and add quite a bit to the plot. After all, it is a story about spending a week with the family. 

The book deals with themes like parental decisions, pressure, and how their actions/ words have a long-lasting impact on the kids. Even when things are done with good intentions, they can have negative repercussions. In fact, this is worse since we can’t blame anyone either. 

I wasn’t expecting a health issue as well, but okay. It’s there, so I can’t do anything. At least, the book ends on a positive note, so all is good. 

Miscommunication or lack of proper communication is the conflict, but I think it was handled decently. It felt realistic enough for the characters to think and do what they did. 

My main reason for a relatively low rating is my expectations. I wanted more from the main couple. They did have the required conversations (eventually and in instalments), but I hoped for a bit more banter and tension rather than monologues. 

A little something was missing, which made me reluctant to give it a higher rating (though I am rounding it up since I enjoyed the book). 

To summarize, Yours for the Season is a cozy romance with strong family vibes. It’s a nice read that can leave you with some thoughts and a smile on your face. 

Thank you, NetGalley and Ballantine | Dell, for the eARC. 

#NetGalley