The Seaside Murders by Helena Dixon - Book Review

Series: The Secret Detective Agency #2

Publication Date: 30th April 2025 

Genre: Historical Mystery 

3.7 Stars 

One Liner: Improvement from the first book 

1941, England 

After solving the previous case, Jane Treen and Arthur Cilento were made the sole members of The Secret Detective Agency by Brigadier Remmington-Blythe. Now, they are sent to a little seaside town to investigate a case. However, soon after they reach the place, a body is found on the beach. 

While there are enough suspects, none of them are willing to cooperate. The duo spends time in Jane’s old home in the village and tries to find the murderer despite the odds. 

The story comes in Jane and Arthur’s third-person POVs. 

My Thoughts: 

I requested a copy before I finished the first book. Since both are to be released back-to-back, I knew the feedback for book #1 may not be applied here yet (not enough time). However, there is some improvement, which assures me that the series might get better. 

And yes, it works as a standalone. 

The sleuths – Jane, Arthur, and Benson (Arthur’s manservant, who is outrageously competent) – come together to solve another case, this time in Jane’s hometown. 

The setting is lovely, though the people are mixed (which seems pretty realistic). The cast of characters is slightly smaller than in the previous book (I think). Of course, it is easy enough to remember who is who. The key ones are well-defined. 

This book has two mysteries – a dead prisoner and a black market racket. Are the cases connected? You’ll have to read to find out! 

The mystery, though simple, is well-planned. I didn’t guess the criminal this time. The reveal made sense, so no complaints. We have a few red herrings and some action to keep the interest levels steady. 

The WWII backdrop is once again seamlessly used in the plot. Be it the raids, bombs, the influx of war prisoners (who are being used as farm workers), or the shortages of certain commodities, everything plays a role in the central plot. 

While I’m still not that impressed with Jane, I do see her better. Imagine being more competent than many men and still being treated as an inferior member or an entry-level assistant. No wonder she acts so extra tough! Still, I’d like her more if she reduced her smoking. After all, it’s her health I’m concerned about! 

The pacing is steady, moderate to fast. However, the book ends at 82%. Yeah, be prepared for this. Otherwise, you’ll be confused and disappointed when the story ends quickly. I checked the % in advance, so I knew what to expect. 

To summarize, The Seaside Murders is a good continuation and provides decent entertainment. I like it enough and will read the next book. Hopefully, the characters will settle down better by then.  

Thank you, NetGalley and Bookouture, for the eARC. 

#NetGalley #TheSeasideMurders