The Many Futures of Maddy Hart by Laura Pearson - Book Review

Publication Date: 04th Feb 2025

Genre: Women’s Fiction, Romance  

2.7 Stars 

One Liner: It's not you, it's me! 

Every time, Maddy thinks she found the one and takes things with them into the bedroom, she blanks out and goes into the future. There, she sees herself with the guy ten years down the lane. Let’s just say, these little glimpses are enough to make her run and not look back. 

However, Maddy meets Oliver and sees a happy and beautiful future with him… but only if she breaks his heart now. Should Maddy destroy her present for a future she sees? 

The story comes in Maddy’s first-person POV in different timelines (neatly marked). 

My Thoughts: 

Well, no way I can resist a premise like this! I’ve read one book by the author and liked it. However, it also made me expect a certain writing style and not finding it here took a while to get used to. 

Since the FMC is twenty-six, she is clearly not mature enough for a heavier writing style. In that sense, the overall vibe fits the characters perfectly. The narration is also fast-paced in the first half. 

The concept of blanking out into the future is well done. There’s no confusion at any point. Moreover, it doesn’t feel awkward or give us too many details. Even the intimate scenes fade out. 

Priya surely added some charm to the book (Priya and Anushka seem be to the most popular Indian names used by Western authors, lol). She is a good friend despite the theatrics (Maddy is an actor but Priya excels in drama). I think her track is much better than the central plot though we don’t get a lot of information. 

The subplot involving the stepbrother’s condition is touching and adds much-needed depth to the plot. I also like that it is kept realistic. I like the kid too. His emotions feel real, making me want to give him a hug. 

The uncertainties and difficulties of being a struggling actor are very well presented. Since both main characters are in the same field, their discussions are meaningful and helpful. Rooting for their career success is easy (even if I couldn’t root for their love life). 

The MMC is pretty decent. However, my major issue is that I couldn’t feel/ connect with their relationship at any point. It’s hard to feel their emotions or the love they have for each other. 

Some of Maddy’s decisions aren’t good/ respectful, considering how much she seems to like the guy. In fact, I don’t like quite a few of her decisions. And to think the guy feels he is lucky to have her. If only he knew the truth! 

My issue is the FMC. While it makes sense for her to act immature, her decisions tend to be stupid as well. There’s no other word for it. Though the premise makes it clear a breakup is necessary, the reasons and the whole thought process around it are… annoying. As much as I understand the need to control whatever we can of our future, the FMC spends almost all her time letting the future dictate her actions rather than trying to change the future by taking control of her present. The concept of free will is important in astrology, tarot reading, etc. There are no guarantees even if some people insist otherwise. 

Even if I let this go, the ending is so dissatisfying! I mean, why would you give it such a strange development and end it like that? It feels like a rushed attempt to conclude the story somehow somehow or a sudden switch to lit-fic style ending when the rest is women’s fic. I wish it was better handled.  

To summarize, The Many Futures of Maddy Hart has an irresistible premise and a few worthy themes but it didn’t work for me. This is more of a me problem, so please check other reviews before you decide. 

Thank you, NetGalley and Boldwood Books, for eARC. 

#NetGalley #TheManyFuturesOfMaddyHart