Blog Archive

Thursday, October 3, 2024

Ninetails: Nine Tales by Sally Wen Mao - Book Review

Publication Date: 28th May 2024

Genre: Short Stories

3 Stars

One Liner: Interesting but a mixed collection

Ninetails is a collection of short stories re-imagined and based on the fox spirit in Chinese mythology. It is a feminist anthology dealing with misogyny, immigration, racism, and different types of abuse against women, especially Asian women (by fellow Asians and Westerners).

Apart from the individual short stories, there’s an overarching story set on Angel Island where the Chinese people land in the US. The immigration office decides the fate of these people after the men and women are separated and made to stay in different buildings. The conditions are pathetic and deplorable.

As always, I made notes for each story (presented below with only grammatical edits):

  • The Haunting Of Angel Island

Arrival: Tye arrives at the island for her new job as an interpreter at the immigration office. We get her past and a glimpse of the mythical fox. The beginning of the overarching story. I’m curious!  

Love Doll: What happens when a love doll (a human-sized s*x toy) starts to have feelings? In the first-person POV of the doll, the story takes us through her life and that of its new owners. Falls flat when it should have hit the high note.  

Beasts of the Chase: What happens when a woman decides to turn back into a fox (vixen)? How does her ethnicity affect her life? Okay!

  • The Haunting Of Angel Island

More events at the immigration office. Different women, several stories, and different fates.

Turtle Head Epidemic: Meng Li was an eighteen-year-old student when the turtle head epidemic swept Singapore. Was it because of a dead pig, a woman, or a fox spirit? This should have been better.

The Fig Queen: What happens when a woman with a troubled life becomes tiny and someone else takes her place? A story of metamorphosis in many ways. Kafkaesque almost!

  • The Haunting Of Angel Island

The overarching story continues as more women arrive and await the decision of the immigration officers.

A Huxians Guide to Seduction Revenge Immortality: The longest story in the book with a first and second-person narration. Well-written and better than the previous ones.

The Girl with Flies Coming Out of Her Eyes: Started great but I soon lost interest! The title says it all. Won’t reveal anything else.

  • The Haunting Of Angel Island

More women, ghosts, spirits, and opposite faiths; believe your God or the White God?

Lotus Stench: The story of a fox spirit and a ghost (woman, obv.), and that ties them together. An interesting read.

The Crush: Another lengthy story about love… or as the title says crush. How do crushed manifest? What to do with them? Feels more mellow than the other stories.  

  • The Haunting Of Angel Island

Tye is the focus again as the connecting storyline comes to an end.

Departure: What kind of departure can this be? After all, there are many ways to depart! Surreal… (which is the aim of the collection).

Thanks to a review by Sarah, I went into the book with fewer expectations. This helped since most stories didn’t have much impact and felt they couldn’t reach their potential. A couple of stories were above-average but most were the kind I forgot a day after reading (the notes saved me).

Fortunately, the overarching piece is a lot better. And, I now know some random information about figs, wasps, bees, foxes, etc.

To summarize, Ninetails has its moments with poetic prose and surreal situations. However, the stories have a varied impact, which dilutes the overall enjoyment.

Thank you, NetGalley and Penguin Books, for a copy of the book. 

#NetGalley #Ninetails

No comments:

Post a Comment